Friday, May 29, 2009

Atop my soap box

This article was in the local paper a few weeks ago. I try not to pull out my soap box too often (although other people, including Joe, may disagree). I also don't use the blog as a venue for my soap box, but in an attempt to help me articulate my thoughts on this issue, I am this time.

I will preface this by saying that I firmly believe that the biggest key to parenting is to do what works best for you and your family. In the past few weeks I have been part of several conversations on the topic of praising children. Since Lucy was born, I have made a concerted effort to not overuse the words "good job" or to overuse the idea of praise. My choice in this parenting matter sometimes gets me some odd looks or doubtful comments by others in the conversations. I consciously chose this as a parent and have become so accustomed to it that I find myself cringing when I hear "good job" thrown my child's way.

Don't get me wrong, I am proud of my children. I love them dearly and share great joy in seeing them discover and learn new things, and when they find success in something they are doing. I find the greatest joy though when I see that their success and pride stems internally rather than from pleasing me or from gaining acceptance from an external source. I already see this happening with Lucy. When she accomplishes something that she didn't think she could do, she will proudly exclaim, "I did it!" and boast a big grin. She doesn't necessarily look to me to provide the feedback or for my approval.

To no fault of my parents, I grew up on much praise. As the article mentions, as a child of the 80's the philosophy was that a child's confidence was built upon praise. I am a product of the philosophy at the time, as my children will be a product of all of the parenting philosophies today and they will likely find faults with those 30 years from now. To this day I am hungry for praise. I thrive on it at work. I have to coach myself not to do things in order to please other people, but rather to do things that make me happy. My conscious decision to not overuse praise with my children is out of a hope for them to build confidence through figuring out what makes them happy and to be proud of their accomplishments because they feel good about what they did.

You may be thinking, "if you don't say good job to a child, then what do you say!?" Let me give you some examples:

-Rather than saying "good job, I love your picture" you may instead reflect on what they are doing and say "wow, look at all of the lines on your picture. You are sure using a lot of colors" or, "you sure are working hard on that picture."
-Rather than saying "good job, you took your bath" or "good job, you ate all of your dinner", you may instead say "you really didn't want to take a bath, but you did it" or "you ate all of your vegetables".

I must also give credit where credit is due. And although I had much praise growing up, I get many of these ideas from Nana, and the philosophies where she teaches. So, thank you FCC for inspiring me.

2 comments:

Carolyn said...

Ha, I've read this article before too and it brings up some good points. Perhaps it's because you/I (use to) work in education and you see the effects of it a lot more than other folks, but I think having a good balance is what's important.

Donice said...

That is beautifully said, Christiane, and it is so lovely when you begin to see their own pleasure and good feelings about their discoveries and hurdles.

This past week I went to the end-of-year "performance" at my grandson's child care setting. It was a good example of how things can seem, to some I guess, like a good idea but are really wrong for children. The saddest moment, to me, was when the "graduating" 5 year olds were reciting their addresses for the assembled adults. One little girl, when asked where she lived, said "I live at home" very quietly. Almost everyone laughed. Did she not do a "good job"? She does live at home.
I'm glad there is room on your soapbox for more of us!